
Deciding who inherits a family business is rarely straightforward. Many clients we work with face a familiar dilemma: one child works full-time in the business whether it is a farm partnership or small limited company for instance, while others have pursued different careers. How do you divide your assets fairly?
The question of fairness is difficult – it comes down to the two different concepts of equity and equality. Leaving everything to the child who works the business may seem fair in terms of contribution and continuity, but what about the other children? Conversely, splitting everything equally may feel morally right, but could risk the business’s future if the working child cannot afford to buy out siblings.
A few key considerations can help guide this difficult decision:
1. Continuity of the business
The child who works within the business often has the skills, knowledge, and relationships needed to keep the business running. Preserving the enterprise may require leaving them the majority, or all, of the asset.
2. Financial balance for other beneficiaries
Other children may be entitled to an inheritance too. This might be achieved through cash gifts, life insurance, or investments. But when making these choices it is important to consider whether inheritance tax (IHT) will be due — and where the funds to pay it will come from.
3. Tax planning
Certain gifts can be structured to be tax-efficient. For example, lifetime gifts to children, or gifts into trust, can sometimes reduce IHT. Planning in advance is crucial to ensure the estate can meet tax obligations without forcing the sale of key business assets.
4. Legal challenges
It is important to remember that not providing for a child, even when an adult — and even if they are not involved in the business — could lead to a claim under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. Careful planning and clear documentation can reduce the risk of disputes and help ensure your wishes are upheld.
5. Clear documentation
Whatever decision is made, it should be recorded in a will or trust deed. This avoids ambiguity and reduces the risk of conflict.
6. Family business and land
Some clients are concerned about unintentionally providing the working child with a benefit from their estate which stretches beyond their involvement in the business. It can be a point of contention if you had imagined the business to continue in the family name and it is later sold. If the business is a farm, or owns land, some clients consider adding an overage clause in the land title. This means that if the child who inherits the business ever sells the land — for example, for development — the other children would be entitled to a share of the uplift in value. Careful drafting is essential to ensure the overage clause is enforceable and aligns with your overall estate plan.
Ultimately, there is no one-size-fits-all solution. Each family and business is unique, and the best answer depends on the estate’s size, the number of beneficiaries, and your own hopes for the business in the future. Taking time to plan carefully, to consider tax implications, and to then communicate intentions clearly can prevent conflict and ensure the family business survives for generations.
If you are facing decisions about dividing a family business, farm, or other significant estate assets, one of our Private Client team can help you explore options that balance fairness, practicality, and tax efficiency.